![]() You want a clear model of the world to be able to achieve your goals. These two concepts are obviously related. ( Instrumental Rationality) - Whatever your goals are, be them selfish or altruistic, there are better and worse ways to achieve them, and instrumental rationality helps you figure this out. ( Epistemic Rationality) - Learning new things, updating your beliefs based on the evidence, being as accurate as possible, being as close to what is true as possible, etc.Ģ. The method of obtaining an accurate view of reality. There are two different concepts that we refer to when we use the word ‘rationality’:ġ. Straw Vulcan rationality is not the same thing as actual rationality. They don’t fail because rationality failed, but because they aren’t actually being rational. These characters have a sort of fake rationality. Traditionally, you have your ‘rational’ character who thinks perfectly ‘logically’, but then ends up running into trouble, having problems, or failing to achieve what they were trying to achieve. ![]() They are depicted as an ultra-rational race that has eschewed all emotion from their lives.īut is this truly rational? What is rationality?Ī “Straw Vulcan”-an idea originally defined on TV Tropes-is a straw man used to show that emotion is better than logic. The classic Hollywood example of rationality is the Vulcans from Star Trek. Note that it is written in my own words, but all of the ideas should be credited to Julia and her presentation (unless I unintentionally misrepresent any of them!). I wrote a summary of Julia Galef's "The Straw Vulcan" presentation from Skepticon 4. Followup to: Communicating rationality to the public: Julia Galef's "The Straw Vulcan"
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |